What's Old Is New Again

Blazing the trail for historic preservation and adaptive reuse

Old City Hall

Boston, Massachusetts

Once referred to as ‘a lunatic pile of a building’, Old City Hall is now viewed as an award-winning example of historic preservation and adaptive reuse. Built in 1865 as one of the first examples of French Second Empire style in the United States, it was home to Boston’s city council for over a century. When Boston’s ‘new’ City Hall was finished in late 1968, Old City Hall building emerged as surplus property. As pioneers in the adaptive reuse movement, Finegold Alexander advocated for the reuse of the building during a time when old buildings were demolished to make way for new. This project paved the way for the repurposing of landmark buildings across the country in the 1970's and 1980's helping to preserve some of our nations most valuable treasures.

Finegold Alexander designed the renovation and conversion of the building into desirable commercial office and restaurant space. The basic plan for renovation was developed from an understanding of the building’s structure which consisted of exterior and interior bearing walls around an open stairway. The four-story stairway, which did not meet ADA requirements, was utilized as a central core to house elevators, egress stairs, restrooms, circulation corridors, and mechanical chases. Finegold Alexander created new office space around the core, resulting in an extremely efficient and flexible use of floor space. The large arched windows were reglazed and the granite exterior of the building was restored to its original grandeur.

Share via
677,000 SF
Historic preservation, renovation, adaptive reuse
Commercial Office Space, Lobby, Restaurant Dining Room, Commercial Kitchen
1976 AIA National Honor Award for Extended Use
1975 AIA Design Award, New England Regional Council
1973 L.J. Peabody Award for Creative Excellence
1972 Preservation Award, Boston Society of Architects
In the news
No items found.
Project EUI
No items found.
"This is a very successful example of the preservation and adaptive reuse of an existing structure which, through sensitive modifications of a contemporary nature, can bring favorable financial results to an investor without destroying the quality of the elegant and historically important original building."
Jury comment, 1976 AIA Honor Award
No items found.

The exterior of the building was left virtually untouched. The interior layout of the building was strategically reconfigured to bring the building up to code, while maintaining key architectural elements such as the four-story stairway, oak trim and detailing, and arched doorways and openings.

No items found.
"Old City Hall is now an award-winning example of historic preservation and adaptive reuse that stimulated the repurposing of landmark buildings nationally in the 1970s and 80s."
Jeffrey Hantover, City in Time: Boston